A disgruntled Baptist sold his property to St. Joseph’s parish in 1895 with a provision that they build their new church as close to the street as possible so as to block the view of the Baptist Church next door. Hence, St. Joseph’s Church edifice has no front lawn. This beautiful red Medina sandstone structure was dedicated in September 1897.  It is Gothic Revival in style, featuring a cruciform plan with a clear story.

In 1952, when this parish celebrated its centennial, they redecorated the interior to its present appearance. At that time all the Italian marble was added, thereby replacing the original altar, communion rail, and statuary. The mural over the main altar was also added, which is entitled, “The Glorification of St. Joseph.” This depicts St. Joseph rising up into heaven surrounded by many angels and cherubs.

Of particular note are the original stained glass windows which adorn this church. To date the maker is unknown but believed to be European. Three doors in the church contain brilliant cut glass windows made in Corning, New York and installed in 1913. The two largest windows, companion subjects, are interesting as to placement. The Holy Family, in brilliant colors, is in the east transept where it catches the morning sun, highlighting Jesus, Mary, and Joseph. Its counterpart, in drab colors, in the west transept, depicts St. John the Baptist and secular people listening to his preaching.

When this church interior was created, worshippers were expected to be dazzled, as are people who enter today.